Why Can't I Clean a Hacked Machine?
Last modified: October 12, 2020
root account is compromised, users often ask how they can “clean” their server. To put it as succinctly as possible: without knowing every action that has ever taken place on a server, it is impossible to prove that the server is completely clean. While it is simple to show a compromised server, showing the opposite, for all intents and purposes, is not.
root-level compromise, the only determinations that can be made about the server’s integrity are the following:
- The server has been hacked.
- The server may still be hacked.
Once a user gains
root access, they can manipulate the server in any way they wish. This means that a hacker can install multiple backdoors, which allow them to regain access to the server. Just because one backdoor is found and removed does not mean that others do not exist. For example, a cron job may run as the
root user and download a backdoor to the
/bin directory each day. You may find the backdoor in the
/bin directory, but miss the cron job that will allow backdoor access to the server again.
Let’s say that 100,000 root-owned files exist on your Linux server. If three of those files are backdoors that grant
root access, how will you know? In addition, many
rootkits hide the presence of backdoors. If a
rootkit instructs your operating system to hide a file, it is unlikely that you will see the file on the disk. Backdoors can also reside in memory only. Most users do not have the resources necessary to continually audit gigabytes of memory for suspicious activity.
Third-party rootkit hunters
chkrootkit can be just as harmful as they are helpful. While they may provide information about known
rootkits, they may also create a false sense of trust and security. If
rootkit detection performed flawlessly every time, there would be no need for multiple products in order to do so. Remember, these utilities check for known malware only, and if their malware library is out of date, they will not detect unknown malware. While they can conduct some heuristics, they can also provide false positives. Most importantly, it is both simple and commonplace for malware developers to evade detection by downloading these utilities and learning how they work.
There will always be unknown malware that has never been and will never be detected. Malware often has variants that operate in many different ways. Without knowing every possible variant, it is impossible to conclusively address the issue.
No official documentation exists for malware because its stealth is how it survives. While independent researchers and antivirus companies provide information about their findings in some cases, no guarantee can be made that the information is entirely accurate or complete. Once that information is released to the public, malware authors may alter their programs to function in a new manner in order to remain undetected.
Solutions for dealing with a compromised server
The only viable solutions for handling a hacked server are the following:
- Migrate the accounts to a clean server and reinstall the hacked server.
- Restore the server from a snapshot. However, the server could have been compromised long before the issue was known. If so, this solution may still leave the server compromised.
If you believe your server has been compromised, we recommend you contact cPanel Technical Support. If we determine that your server is compromised, you or your system administrator will need to follow the solutions above to resolve the issue.